DealLawyers.com Blog

November 17, 2026

Post-Closing Adjustments: Keeping Your True Up Out of Court

This Mayer Brown blog takes a look at the avalanche of accountant true-up lawsuits that have been working their way through the Delaware Chancery Court this year. It provides some key takeaways from recent judicial decisions, reviews how these true-up mechanisms work and how Delaware courts approach them, and offers some practical guidance on how to draft true-up provisions in order to avoid ending up spending years in litigation. Here’s an excerpt:

1. Label the process clearly. State expressly in the PPA or earnout provision that the dispute mechanism is an accountant true-up and that the accountant acts as an expert, not an arbitrator. This generally removes much of the ambiguity that would otherwise require court review.

2. Define precisely what the accountant can decide. The scope of the accountant’s authority is the central and by far most litigated issue in PPA and earnout disputes. Traditional true-up provisions are often silent or unclear on this key aspect, opening the door to court involvement. Parties can help themselves most by surveying the true-up provision and clearly identifying what elements are and are not within the accountant’s expertise.

3. Be clear about the interplay between the true-up provision and other remedies like indemnification and representations and warranties insurance (RWI). Many of the opinions turn on whether a claim belongs in the true-up or in the indemnification regime. Parties should state expressly that items resolved through the true-up cannot be recovered again as indemnifiable losses and that a claim being styled as a representation breach does not take it out of the true-up if it concerns the calculation of a PPA or earnout component. They should also check that the RWI policy’s exclusions for PPAs line up with that allocation, so neither side ends up without a forum or a source of recovery.

The blog’s discussion of the need to define precisely what the accountant can decide is accompanied by a very helpful deep dive into the matters are best resolved by an accountant, those that are potentially within an accountant’s expertise, and those that are best suited to resolution by a court.

– John Jenkins

Take Me Back to the Main Blog Page

Blog Preferences: Subscribe, unsubscribe, or change the frequency of email notifications for this blog.

UPDATE EMAIL PREFERENCES

Try Out The Full Member Experience: Not a member of DealLawyers.com? Start a free trial to explore the benefits of membership.

START MY FREE TRIAL