DealLawyers.com Blog

April 29, 2008

“Witches Brew”: SEC Accuses Trader of Rumormongering on Deal

As noted in this NY Times article on Friday (and this Wilson Sonsini memo), the SEC settled a case with a former securities who allegedly spread false rumors to profit from a pending buyout of Alliance Data Systems by the Blackstone Group (the deal tanked later due to other reasons). The SEC said this was its first “rumormongering” case.

According to the NY Times article, the trader allegedly “fabricated a rumor that Alliance Data’s takeover was being renegotiated to $70 a share from $81.75 a share. The trader said that Alliance Data’s board was meeting to discuss the revised proposal. At the time, Alliance Data’s board members were on a plane and could not be reached for comment.” Trading in Alliance Data’s stock was suspended due to heavy volume caused by the rumor, which the trader had sent via instant messages to 31 other traders and other market participants. He was short selling the stock at the time.

Reading the SEC’s complaint, it’s not clear if the trader knew that the board was on a plane and unavailable – my guess is that he didn’t know (and thus was unlucky because if they had been reached and quashed the rumor more quickly, the damages would have been reduced and perhaps this case wouldn’t have been brought or the penalty would be been less than the $130,000 he ended up paying.

In the SEC’s press release, SEC Chairman Cox noted ““The commission will vigorously investigate and prosecute those who manipulate markets with this witch’s brew of damaging rumors and short sales.” It will be interesting to see if the SEC’s Enforcement Division will be bringing more of these cases, particularly due to the heightened interest in hedge funds and their failures to adopt adequate insider trading compliance programs (see Dave Lynn’s recent blog on the SEC’s Section 21(a) Report involving the investigation of the Retirement Systems of Alabama).